There is a lot of discussion (in certain circles) as to why Star Trek Enterprise failed as a show. This is to be the last season and despite admirable efforts at raising the 50 million necessary to give the show one more year, I do not believe UPN will go for it. There is talk about Sci Fi Channel (unlikely) and Spike TV (more talk of it) picking up the series, but I don’t think UPN wants to part with the liscense.
UPN wanted the best sci-fi show on t.v. They kept the show on Friday nights, even though Sci-Fi channel had much higher rated shows on during that time slot. One thing that UPN could have done to cause the show to flourish, would have been to give up the friday nights and choose another day of the week. However that isn’t the biggest reason the show failed in my opinion. What has gone wrong with near every star trek series since Star Trek The Next Generation is they have too many multi-part episodes. Season Two of Enterprise may as well have been one long episode. You miss one, you’re out of the loop. UPN I think did this intentionally to try to pressure fans to watch it constantly. However it totally turned off the casual star trek fan. Voyager at least incorporated the mission home throughout the series in such a way that each episode was independent. I’m glad I’ve been able to get Deep Space Nine on DVD, because it had the same problem (though not as bad as Enterprise)-I couldn’t keep up with the series and eventually didn’t worry about watching it. Each show should be a self contained episode as much as possible. There is a whole misguided marketing idea based on season finales being half of a two part episode to ensure viewers being watching it again the next season. They took that concept and extended it to running multi-part episodes within a single season. That is why Star Trek Enterprise failed, not just because Sci-Fi channel had a better line up with Star Gate, Star Gate Atlantis, and Battle Star Gallatica.
Todays viewing public are all A.D.D. We are hit with stimuli from all over, people use the net more than they watch television. Reality T.V. shows bloom, demanding an audiences attention for a limited period of time-and end. Expecting to hold an audiences attention by a television show versus reality t.v. programs is rediculous. UPN constantly has been making this mistake. Their simple comedy shows make it because they aren’t demanding on the audience. People don’t have to tune in every week, but nor are they likely to be reward winning shows. The powerhouses that UPN has presented have all failed because UPN kept trying to expect the same level of audience that had before the net and reality t.v. I enjoyed the New Twilight Zone, more than the attempt back in the early 90’s that also ran for one season. I finally got into Jake 2.0, only to have that show cancelled as well.
Television stations have to adapt and stop trying to force people to watch a show without missing a single episode. What ends up happening is people who do miss that one episode can’t get back into the program. Watching shows should be entertainment, not work. I liked Enterprise, wasn’t the best series but it really began picking up. I especially enjoyed learning more about Vulcan mysticism. So long as UPN expects too much from their programing, using serial episodes (like soap operas) to ensure an audience-their potential hits are going to fail. The same goes with Fox. Arrested Development might be cancelled because it only has an average audience of 6 million people. The show does depend on what has happened in previous weeks and would be very hard for someone to get into who has never seen it before-or has missed a number of episodes.
At any rate that’s my rant. Eventually I hope that being able to sell DVD box sets of a show will cover cost of production, then it doesn’t matter if you have a 10 part episode or not. I don’t think with Enterprise it was so much the story had to be told over several parts, I think it was an intentional ploy by UPN execs to make their audience watch the show-to work at watching the show; just like how having a two part season finale has people tune in for the next season.